The rollercoaster ride of silver in the United States has reached a critical junction. After the "Historic 3-Day Crash" that saw prices dive from $120 to the $70s, and the subsequent rebound back to $85, many US retail investors are asking one urgent question: "Is it time to exit and sell my silver?"
The answer depends on whether you are a short-term trader or a long-term believer in the "Silver Story."
The Case for Selling (Booking Profits)
1. The "Hawkish" Fed Shift
The primary reason to consider selling a portion of your holdings is the changing stance of the Federal Reserve. With Kevin Warsh nominated as the next Fed Chair, the market is pricing in a much stronger US Dollar and tighter monetary discipline. A strong dollar is traditionally bad for silver. If you have made 100%+ gains in the last year, locking in some profits now might be a smart move to protect your capital.
2. Extreme Volatility (The Stress Factor)
Silver has recently shown "meme-stock" levels of volatility, with 15-20% swings in a single session. For many American families who bought silver for "safety," this level of risk is becoming uncomfortable. Selling enough to cover your initial investment while keeping the rest (playing with "house money") is a common strategy being adopted right now.
The Case for Holding (Why the Rally Isn't Over)
1. Structural Supply Deficit
Despite the price crash, the physical reality hasn't changed. The world is still in a massive silver deficit. US industries—from Solar energy in Texas to EV manufacturing in Detroit—cannot function without silver. This industrial demand provides a "floor" that prevents the price from crashing to zero.
2. US-India Trade Developments
The new trade deals and tariff adjustments (reducing them to 18%) have re-ignited global demand. If you sell now, you might miss the second leg of the bull run that some analysts predict could still reach $150 later this year once the government shutdown and debt ceiling issues create fresh panic.
3. Inflation Hedge
With the US government facing a massive deficit and a partial shutdown, silver remains one of the few assets that cannot be "printed." As long as inflation remains a concern for American households, silver will hold its value as a hard asset.
Final Verdict: What Should You Do?
- If you are a Short-Term Trader: It might be wise to sell on these "relief rallies" (when the price bounces back to $85-$90) and wait for more stability.
- If you are a Long-Term Investor: Don't let the "paper market" noise scare you. The industrial and strategic importance of silver is higher than ever in 2026. Holding (HODLing) through the volatility has historically rewarded patient investors.
Expert Advice: Follow the "Trailing Stop-Loss" method. Instead of selling everything at once, set a price (like $75) where you will automatically sell if the market drops again. This protects your gains while keeping you in the game for the next rally.